Friday, 20 December 2013

The Week in Review: Cameron's immigration doublethink - Politics.co.uk

Did your email system distort this newsletter? Click here to see it online. To make sure emails from Politics.co.uk don’t go into your junk folder, please add us to your email contacts. To stop receiving emails such as this, please update your preferences or unsubscribe here.

Being prime minister often requires the ability to hold two contradictory views at the same time.

We can see this most clearly in David Cameron's attitude to immigration.

As an educated metropolitan man, Cameron knows that Britain needs immigration in order to grow. He knows that without it, the economy will fail along with any hopes he has of remaining prime minister.

But he also knows that a large percentage of the British public do not want any more immigration. His solution is to appear to be doing something about it, while in practice doing almost nothing of the sort.

This is the 'something must be done' approach to governing. Something must always be done even when it can't be done and won't be done. We saw this in the decision to send anti-immigration 'go home' vans around central London.

Nobody in the Home Office seriously believed this would deter illegal immigration and of course it didn't. But something needed to be done and in this case sending a BNP style "truth truck" around London was that something.

We saw it again with Theresa May's announcement this week that she intends to cap EU immigration. This is a more extreme version of the something must be done strategy, in that this something does not even need to be seen to be done.

Theresa May knows that she cannot cap EU immigration. She knows that a cap would be illegal under EU law, even if she could get agreement from the Liberal Democrats, which she can't. But something always needs to be done.

The other something that needed to be done this week was the release of Howard Davies report on airport expansion. All three political parties agree that something needs to be done on this issue, but none of them are willing to be the ones doing that something.

Labour tried and failed to expand Heathrow in government. David Cameron opposed expansion at the time but has now reportedly changed his mind. We can't be sure of this however, because he's announced that he'll only confirm what his views are after the next election. Something needs be done, but only if we're then stopped from voting on that something.

But if Cameon does choose to expand airports before the election, then it would take an amazing act of doublethink. It would require the ability to believe that what Britain most needs is to be opened up to the world, while also believing that what Britain most needs is to be closed off from it.

"Britain's borders must be shut," he will say, before adding "and once they're all shut, we'll build a brand new hub airport so we can get millions more people through them again."

Something must always be done. It would just be helpful if our politicians could work out what that something was first before doing it.

The season of good will

Ed Miliband and Nick Clegg both had their Christmas parties for journalists this week. These are quite awkward occasions as the host shuffles round the room enthusiastically welcoming people who have spent the past year relentlessly slagging them off.

They put up with it in the hope that we might be slightly less likely to put our boots in in future, if we've shared a glass of free wine and a few canapes with them.

Whether or not this works is hard to say, but I did have a few conversations with other journalists in which it was agreed that both Clegg and Miliband have had a relatively good year. I thought this was a theory worth checking out when I returned home.

A quick look at Clegg's public satisfaction ratings this morning showed that they have gone down from -22 a year ago to -33 now. Miliband meanwhile has gone from -3 a year ago to -25 now. Miliband and Clegg may have had a good year, but if they have then the public hasn't noticed.

Best of News

University apologises for banning 'blasphemous' T-Shirts

London School of Economics apologised for censoring students

Students ordered to cover up T-Shirts depicting Jesus and Mohammed or risk being physically removed.

Let off the hook: Corporations allowed to avoid billions in tax

City of London: Multinational companies accused of aggressive tax avoidance

The UK tax authorities routinely hold back from chasing multinational corporations for billions of pounds in unpaid taxes, a committee of MPs has found.

George Osborne lost £230 million on state-owned bank sale

George Osborne: "another step in the long journey"

George Osborne lost taxpayers at least £230 million on the part sell-off of Lloyd's bank, despite having claimed to have made a profit, the government's spending watchdog have found.

The end: Isa Muazu appeal refused

Judgement passed: Muazu loses deportation case

Supporters of Isa Muazu ran out of options to prevent his deportation this evening, after the court of appeal refused his case.

Best of Comment and Analysis

The Week According to Sean Dilley

The week according to Sean Dilley

Broadcaster and general nuisance Sean Dilley gives his take on the week in politics.

Comment: Three embarrassing truths about Cameron's porn filter

Jane Fae: David Cameron has demonstrated both ignorance of the internet, and a truly irresponsible attitude to policing it.

Blocking and filtering has finally arrived and many of the drawbacks warned of by those of us who actually know a thing or two about the internet, are now all too apparent.

The hidden stories of the people Britain will deport tonight

Hidden stories of failed asylum seekers

Maybe you believe them. Maybe you don't. Here are the stories of the people being deported back to Nigeria tonight.

The sinking of Boris Island

Boris Johnson: surging to defeat

With a few clicks of his keyboard, Sir Howard Davies today ruled all of Boris Johnson's work null and void.

May's cynical attempt to create division will lead to racist attacks on our streets

Theresa May: Irresponsible hysteria?

Theresa May's appeal to hysteria over an influx of Romanian and Bulgarian immigrants on our streets could trigger a violent backlash against the newcomers.

Our club: Sports clubs to get young people working

VIDEO: Morrisons is pioneering a new programme in famous sporting venues around the UK to help young unemployed people get back into work.

BHA: Right to die with dignity is a fundamental human right

The 'right to die' cases of Jane Nicklinson and Paul Lamb will be heard at the Supreme Court this week.

Rethink: Independent review of fit-for-work tests does not go far enough

Review of government’s controversial Work Capability Assessment (WCA) fails to go far enough.

RSPCA urges Westminster to follow Welsh Government’s lead on fly grazing legislation

The new legislation will equip local authorities in Wales with additional powers to tackle fly grazing and abandonment problems.

NASUWT: Key stage 2 results highlight the lie that education standards are falling

“The efforts of teachers and pupils are often overshadowed by the obsession with performance league tables."

CIOT: Tax advisers welcome changes to employee ownership structures

CIOT backs decision to provide capital gains tax relief for business owners upon transferring ownership to employees.

BSA: Autumn Statement: Hard-pressed savers will continue to feel the pinch

The Building Societies Association comments on the autumn statement.

IET: Autumn Statement: "Skills gap is a challenge that won’t go away overnight"

Engineering and technology must remain government priority says IET in response to the Autumn Statement.

CIOT: Autumn Statement: Cautious welcome for new Social Enterprises tax relief

CIOT welcomes Autumn Statement confirmation of new tax relief for investment by individuals in Social Enterprises.

This email has been sent to you by Politics.co.uk because you previously registered on our site. To stop receiving emails like this please update your preferences or unsubscribe here. Politics.co.uk, South Quay Plaza 2, 183 Marsh Wall, London, E14 9SH. Registered in England with company number 07092149.

No comments:

Post a Comment