Friday, 12 September 2014

Week in Review: England finally wakes up - Politics.co.uk

Did your email system distort this newsletter? Click here to see it online. To make sure emails from Politics.co.uk don’t go into your junk folder, please add us to your email contacts. To stop receiving emails such as this, please update your preferences or unsubscribe here.

When Orwell got back from the Spanish civil war, he complained of the lethargy of his home country.

"The pigeons in Trafalgar Square, the red buses, the blue policemen – all sleeping the deep, deep sleep of England, from which I sometimes fear that we shall never wake till we are jerked out of it by the roar of bombs."

England was woken up rather smartly a few years later, as Hitler's military ambitions became impossible to contain. But Orwell's analysis of the English political condition is accurate: perpetual sleepiness turning into a surprisingly formidable competence once forced into action.

A similar pattern has been evident from the Scottish independence referendum. It was safely assumed it would be a strong win for the union and for good reason. In early August, YouGov gave 'No' a 22-point lead. Last Sunday morning, it put 'Yes' ahead by one per cent. That was the bomb that woke up England.

The sleep, in truth, had not just been about the referendum. It had been about Britain's entire constitutional arrangement, from half-finished devolution to the West Lothian question. It was about a Westminster elite hated so widely and deeply that anyone – from Alex Salmond to Nigel Farage – could win an election merely by saying they were against them.

No matter what happens on September 18th, when Scotland actually goes to the polls, this will have been a historic week in English politics, because this is the week that its political structure decided to change. The reforms promised to Scotland in the event of a 'No' vote will make demands for English devolution impossible to resist. And a 'Yes' vote will necessarily trigger wide-ranging constitutional reforms. No matter what happens, nothing will be quite the same.

By Friday, Nick Clegg was putting his name to a report from IPPR North on devolution of power to metropolitan areas. One of the central questions in the years to come will be how to break up English politics so that its population size does not imbalance Wales and Scotland in a union which will inevitably go down the road of federalism.

But that entails the 'No' camp winning the vote. Recent polls have shown 'Yes' falling back behind again, leading some commentators to conclude that Scots stared down the cliff edge and decided not to jump. Perhaps, but the high levels of voter registration and reports of very high postal vote participation indicate that 'Yes' may have prepared a groundswell of support on polling day. The only reliable fact is that it is going to be tight, very tight.

Westminster has done little to help. David Cameron, Ed Miliband and Clegg cancelled their participation in PMQs and headed up to Scotland. It was like trying to cure a headache with techno music. Given that Salmond had succeeded in making the election about Scotland vs Westminster, the active and visible participation of Westminster was not what the doctor ordered.

Cameron was placed on a seat for his speech in which he referred to the "effing Tories", presumably to give him a dash of humility. Humility does not come naturally to him, but he looked genuinely shaken. Nevertheless, his presence will not have helped Better Together. The same can be said for Nigel Farage, who headed up to Scotland on Friday, as if he was trying to secretly sabotage the union.

To a man with a hammer, every problem looks like a nail. Similarly, Westminster does not know how to react to the problem of itself in a way which does not involve itself. The three leaders needed to adopt the humble posture Cameron had until now and stay well away. Their presence is a greater boost to the 'Yes' camp than anything Salmond could organise.

Firm answers are coming. This week was historic. But next week will be the biggest British politics has had for 300 years. The roar of bombs may sound again, but louder.

Best of News

Will the Tories wreck the overseas aid bill?

Michael Moore speaks in the Commons chamber during the second reading debate of his overseas aid bill

All of Westminster's three main parties promised it in their 2010 manifestos – but it's taken a single backbencher to give their pledge to lock down 0.7% of Britain's gross national income on aid spending a chance of becoming law.

Rotherham abuse: The man Westminster wants to quit defies MPs

EDL protests against Shaun Wright in Rotherham

The man who ran Rotherham's children's services for five years while authorities took a "blatant" disregard to widespread child sexual exploitation faces MPs later.

Lib Dems ready to decriminalise all drugs

Clegg has pushed hard on drug reform since a visit to Colombia, where he met former guerrilla fighters and victims of the conflict in the country

Personal possession of all drugs should be decriminalised, the Liberal Democrats announce

Best of Comment and Analysis

How did a detainee die in Morton Hall immigration centre?

Barbed wire: Events behind the fence at Morton Hall are hard to piece together

However Rubel Ahmed died, he was a victim of Morton Hall detention centre

How a Cold War with Russia could save the environment

A Rosneft production facility. Britain relies on Russia for 15% of its gas supplies

Stripping away the EU's reliance on Russian gas could help the planet, too

Britain secretly decriminalised cannabis – and it's a disaster

Cannabis: Semi-decriminalisation does more harm than good

How a bit of under-the-table liberalism sucked even more young black and Asian kids into the criminal justice system

Drug law reform isn't theory anymore – it's practise

Drug reform: From theory to practice

A new global report by Kofi Annan, Richard Branson and others aims to build on the momentum of the drug reform movement

Comment: No British company should be profiting from Guantánamo

Guantanamo Bay: 'The gulag of our times'

Whether ministers like it or not, G4S' Guantanamo Bay contract associates Britain with the day-to-day running of an illegal torture facility.

Key industry leaders gather in Scarborough for fuel poverty summit

This Monday 250 industry leaders and key stakeholders will meet in Scarborough to debate the issues affecting the 4.5 million UK households in fuel poverty, as part of leading fuel poverty charity NEA’s 3-day Annual Conference.

Employee benefits and expenses - simplification must not come at the cost of fairness for vulnerable employees

The Low Incomes Tax Reform Group (LITRG) has welcomed proposed reforms to the employee benefits and expenses regime, which should reduce administrative burdens for employers.

Government cyber security programme: a lack of skills is a big concern

The National Audit Office has published an update for the Committee of Public Accounts on the Government’s National Cyber Security Programme.

NOAH welcomes release of Commission’s proposals package for revised legislation for veterinary medicines and medicated feed

The European Commission in Brussels has today published its proposed package for revised legislation for veterinary medicines and medicated feed.

Cyber security measures must be part of Government’s smart metering programme

As the Public Accounts Committee publishes its report on the Update on Preparations for Smart Metering, engineers are warning of the need for cyber security measures to be an integral part of the programme.

Anti gay laws fuelling rise in global homophobia

Punitive and discriminatory anti-gay laws are fuelling rising homophobia around the world, the NASUWT, the largest teachers’ union in the UK, told the TUC Congress in Liverpool.

This email has been sent to you by Politics.co.uk because you previously registered on our site. To stop receiving emails like this please update your preferences or unsubscribe here. Politics.co.uk, South Quay Plaza 2, 183 Marsh Wall, London, E14 9SH. Registered in England with company number 07092149.

No comments:

Post a Comment