Friday, 9 May 2014

Week in Review: When did the coalition get as bad as New Labour? - politics.co.uk

Did your email system distort this newsletter? Click here to see it online. To make sure emails from Politics.co.uk don’t go into your junk folder, please add us to your email contacts. To stop receiving emails such as this, please update your preferences or unsubscribe here.

There was a time not so long ago, when the coalition was fairly liberal. It was one of the feted areas of overlap which the Liberal Democrats and Tories shared. Ken Clarke was in charge of justice, with that whole relaxed, moderate bonhomie he's got going on. Theresa May was talking about civil liberties. Admittedly she did it with all the authenticity of a hostage reading out a note given to her by her captors, but the words came out her mouth nonetheless. Efforts to replace the Human Rights Act with a British bill of rights just resulted in a few guffaws from Clarke and Nick Clegg.

That was only four years ago - a parliament, if we hadn't arbitrarily decided to make a parliament five years instead of four. And look how things have changed.

The state authoritarianism of the New Labour years is alive and well in the coalition. This week, May, that lady who cared so much about Brit's cherished freedoms, was demanding MPs give her the power to strip us of our citizenship. She could always do this, but before she had to prove we were not conducive to the public good and had another country we could belong to. Not so anymore. Under her new plans she can take away our passports regardless of whether we have somewhere else to stay. Proper, old school, Saddam Hussein statelessness. There's no court order. Just her deciding you're not British anymore.

Norman Baker, the Lib Dem's man in the Home Office, managed to extract some middling concessions from her but nothing which would survive contact with the cold light of day. MPs voted it through by 305 to 239. The Lords will fight against it, as they did to legislation like this during the Labour years (when John Reid tried to do something similar).

Meanwhile, MPs were warning that HMRC might have gone too far with its plans to access Brits' bank account directly and take out whatever money it decides it's owed. Not only that, but it can do this on money which it thinks it is owed in expectation of winning the case. George Osborne has tired of waiting for a proper process to be complete before he gets to dip into someone's bank account, so he smuggled this into the fine print of the Budget. Not many people noticed it at the time, excluding us of course, but parliamentarians have finally sat up and taken note, so we might see some wavering on this.

In the immigration detention centres dotted around Britain - the places no-one ever talks about where we hold people who have committed no crime - mass protests were kicking off. Hundreds of men in four institutions were refusing the leave the courtyard and going on hunger strike. These centres remain Britain's dirty little secret - uncovered by the press, unmentioned by politicians. But behind their walls, the inmates remain.

Grayling pressed ahead with his plans for huge children's prisons, as if he wanted to play the bad guy in a straight-to-DVD Dickensian parable. The evidence on these insitutions is very clear: they are damaging. They cause harm. Grayling is doing it anyway, in much the same way that Labour home secretaries tried (and failed) to press ahead with titan prisons, despite the warnings from experts. You can say it until you are blue in the face: small local prisons work. Large central prisons don't. We've known this for years. It makes no difference.

The justice secretary once again failed to write back to the coalition of authors who have asked for a meeting to voice their concerns about the ban on parcels being sent to prisoners - including books. His prison minister was asked a series of parliamentary questions about the amount of contraband getting into prisons through parcels in the lead-up to the ban. He admitted he had no idea, whch did sort of put the lie to the assurances he had been giving about why the ban was necessary.

This week the prison governors themselves made their voices heard. If the tough new rules, which were introduced last November, were not changed they could not guarantee that they could deal with the "instability" they were creating. This was as dire and serious a warning as could be imagined: the people who run prisons, making it clear that they were becoming unmanageable because of the actions of the secretary of state.

When did the coalition get this bad? There were lots of signs along the way - the decision to replace Clarke, the 'go home' vans, the rise of Ukip after Eastleigh, the constant furious pressure of the red tops and the Tory backbenchers. Like a relationship that lost its sparkle, it's hard to identify the precise moment it happened.

But it has certainly happened. The government which in 2010 made a promise to return civil liberties to Britain has become just as authoritarian as its predecessor.

Best of news

Miliband told to put sustainability in schools

Ed Miliband likes to "chew the cud" on sustainability, MPs say

Labour should commit to including sustainable development in the national curriculum, a senior backbencher says

Bucking the trend: Poll shows huge opposition to privately-run public services

G4S: Huge levels of public distrust to outsourced public services

Public overwhelmingly opposed to private firms running public services, new poll reveals

Cinderella law: Emotional abuse 'risks criminalising millions'

Emotional abuse is not currently a criminal offence - unlike physical and sexual abuse

'Cinderella law' set to criminalise emotional abuse "creates more problems than it solves", Frank Furedi warns

Peers desperate to get Britain fracking

Much of Britain contains significant shale gas resources

Lords give ministers the green light to strip back environmental regulation of fracking

Farage celebrates 'Ukip's Clause IV moment' as he surrounds himself with black candidates

Farage says presence of ethnic minority candidates his 'Clause IV moment'

Nigel Farage stands on stage with an assortment of black and ethnic minority Ukip candidates, as he attempts to dispel perceptions his party is racist

Labour set to lose out as young voters give politics two fingers

Labour could do with support from young vote - but will they show up at the ballot box?

Only four in ten of first-time-voters will bother showing up in 2015

Ethnic minorities soar in number - and they don't vote Tory

Cricket test? Ethnic minorities are booming - and they don't vote for Norman Tebbit's party

Soaring ethnic minority births should give Conservatives pause for thought

Clegg signs 'roadmap' to ending war on drugs

Clegg adopts more confident stance on drug reform

Nick Clegg is among the signatories to a controversial report outlining a roadmap toward ending the 'war on drugs', as he continues to push for a more liberal approach to the problem

Best of Comment and Analysis

Comment: The court abortion ruling which puts Northern Irish women at risk

Police walk around anti-abortion placards outside the Marie Stopes clinic, the first private clinic to offer abortions to women in Belfast.

A bar on Northern Irish women getting free abortions on the NHS means only the rich can plan their family.

Punishing vulnerability: Why being granted refugee status can make you homeless

Homelessness: A common fate for refugees in Britain

Why being recognised as a refugee can be the beginning of a new nightmare

Comment: Cameron should apologise for deceiving working parents

Alex Stevenson: Cameron took credit for this letter. Now he should take responsibility

Working parents aren't going to receive £2,000 of tax relief for employing domestic childcare – despite a promise from the PM. The least he can do is say sorry.

European elections 2014: Desperate leaders

European election campaign debate is centring around Britain's future relationship with Brussels

What the campaign launches tell us about this year's elections struggle

NASUWT comments on College of Teaching poll

The outcomes of this poll reflect the longstanding views of the NASUWT on the proposals to establish a College of Teaching.

Mortgage arrears down in first quarter of 2014

Both the number and the proportion of mortgages in arrears fell during the first quarter of 2014, according to new figures from the Council of Mortgage Lenders.

NEA comment on 'Green Deal Home Improvement Fund'

Today the UK Government has released further information on the ‘Green Deal Home Improvement Fund’.

Clarity over public benefit and protections needed for data sharing

Tax professionals are calling on the Government to provide assurances that it is not going to start selling taxpayers’ data.

We need to consider our transport networks as “a whole”, say engineers

The Transport Committee today says that the Government must plan for new road and rail investment by looking at future passenger and freight demand by route or region, not by looking at each in isolation from each other.

A year to go to the Election, charity launches Election Planner to get disengaged groups voting

Exactly one year from the General Election, charity launches new Election Planner to get disengaged groups voting.

HMRC debt proposals contain insufficient curbs on possible abuses

HMRC debt proposals contain insufficient curbs on possible abuses, say LITRG.

BSA Chief Executive calls on sector to mould its future

Speaking at the BSA annual conference in Manchester today, Robin Fieth, Chief Executive of the BSA, called on the building society sector, regulators and policy-makers to think carefully about the future shape of the financial services sector.

This email has been sent to you by Politics.co.uk because you previously registered on our site. To stop receiving emails like this please update your preferences or unsubscribe here. Politics.co.uk, South Quay Plaza 2, 183 Marsh Wall, London, E14 9SH. Registered in England with company number 07092149.

No comments:

Post a Comment