Friday, 4 April 2014

Week in Review: Confidence in immigration? - politics.co.uk

Did your email system distort this newsletter? Click here to see it online. To make sure emails from Politics.co.uk don’t go into your junk folder, please add us to your email contacts. To stop receiving emails such as this, please update your preferences or unsubscribe here.

Supporters of immigration have been on the back foot for a long time.

It is difficult to make a case when the polls are so comprehensively against you. And those who are uncomfortable with the increasingly toxic debate on immigration fall into many disparate, sometimes hostile, categories.

Some are business minded, wanting labour to flow and freely as capital. Others are concerned with the treatment of asylum seekers in Britain's detention centres. These positions have little to unite them, except for a desire to challenge the direction of the debate.

This week saw a growing confidence among those who want a more humane, calm debate on immigration - and more scrutiny of the restrictions which follow from it.

The case of Yashika Bageerathi demonstrated the growing strength of those willing to stand up for immigrants and asylum seekers.

Yashika was a Mauritian 19-year-old who was detained weeks before her A-levels and then deported on an Air Mauritius flight this week. The interviews with her weeping mother, who had been left in the UK, made for a powerful demonstration of how devastating immigration law can be on families.

The case for Yashika was not so much that the asylum decision should be overturned, but that she should be allowed to at least finish her A-levels. The case helped highlight how arbitrary and lacking in natural justice the system can be.

The response was astonishing. A furious social media and telephone campaign against British Airways and Air Mauritius saw them refuse the Home Office request, although the latter airline backed down a little later, possibly after some threatening noises from the Home Office.

The kick-back was immense, with Air Mauritius being hit by a substantial Twitter storm and promises of a boycott. It didn't stop it, but it showed the growing strength and influence of the pro-immigration lobby.

That was also in evidence in Labour's response to a death at Yarl's Wood detention centre on Sunday.

Usually these deaths in custody barely cause a ripple. A handful of blogs might mention them. This time it was a bigger deal. Labour responded swiftly - demanding an investigation into the Serco-run institution.

It had a similar response to the Yashika row, with usually authoritarian shadow home secretary Yvette Cooper making a strong case for a more leniant and humane handling of the case.

Labour is not prone to coming out on the liberal side of the immigration debate and it's not about the start making a habit of it. But the party is evidently prepared to back at least some specific campaigns.

It's worth looking at the opposition as a weather vane . If Labour feels there's political space for a more nuanced position, pro-immigration campaigners should take heart.

In all probability, what we are seeing is a reaction to the rise of Ukip. As the party's influence on the Tories pushes the debate into ever more frenzied terrain, people have become less and less comfortable with it.

The changes taking place are relatively subtle and have not yet secured a major political win, such as the prevention of a deportation or the closure of a detention centre.

But there is a growing sense that those who want a more civilised immigration debate are willing to stand up for themselves.

Best of news

Farage comes out against prison book ban

Farage criticises prison book ban

Farage joins growing chorus of criticism against the prisoner book ban

Denied justice: Domestic abuse victims forced to stay in relationship

Writers for Liberty drop off a parcel of books at the MoJ for Chris Grayling's birthday

Victims of domestic abuse forced to stay with their partner due to cuts to legal aid, damning new finding suggests

Why you can afford to ignore the European elections

Polling booth: Euro election results do little to predict general election performance

No matter how well they do next month, Ukip's support will dwindle by the general election, research suggests

Grayling faces legal threat over prisoner book ban

Chris Grayling could face legal battle over prisoner book ban

Chris Grayling warned that he could face legal proceedings over the prisoner book ban, as the campaign against the policy escalates

Labour can stop the khat ban this afternoon - but will it?

Khat: Will Labour oppose a ban?

Labour can bring Theresa May's illogical ban screeching to a halt today. But we still don't know which way it'll vote.

Crisis of justice: Probation staff and solicitors go on joint strike

Grayling fights fires on multiple fronts

Joint strike by probation staff and solicitors brings parts of the justice system to a standstill, as Chris Grayling faces his latest crisis

Best of Comment and Analysis

How did Maria Miller keep her job?

Clueless: How does a Cabinet secretary survive an expenses scandal?

The sad story of how a Cabinet secretary can survive an expenses scandal

Clegg/Farage debate: The case for the EU is dead

Farage ahead of last night's debate

Supporters of the EU won't argue for it - they only dare argue against leaving it.

Comment: Cameron's Muslim Brotherhood investigation is just a favour to the Saudis

Alastair Sloan: 'In a part of the world where religion is so important, it's unlikely in the near future that any populist movement will not in some way incorporate Islamist thinking'

The PM offers satisfaction to Sisi's murderous Egyptian regime with an investigation into the Muslim Brotherhood

Comment: We're locking people up for the crime of being born outside the UK

Keith Taylor: 'The majority of migrants leaving detention after a year or more are actually released back into the UK, rather than deported'

Britain's use of detention centres is abusive, counter-productive and cripplingly expensive

Comment: Grayling's book ban excuses just don't wash

Caroline Lucas: 'A gift of a book can change not just what you read but who you become'

The justice secretary's defence of the prisoner book ban is weak and contradictory

The Mothers' Day death: What happened to Christine Case?

Detained: Deaths from heart failure are not uncommon in detention centres.

Who was Christine Case and how did she die?

Comment: Why Nick Clegg is wrong to support the prisoner book ban

Frances Crook: 'If a prisoner is lucky enough to get a job working in the kitchen or cleaning the wings the average earning is £8 a week'

The deputy prime minister claims we can send in book to prison libraries - but he doesn't understand how the system works.

Comment: The medieval punishment of Syria continues, ignored by the world

Kristyan Benedict: 'The overall humanitarian situation in Syria remains calamitous'

Tens of thousands are enduring total collective imprisonment under pain of death and yet Westminster still has no sense of urgency

Censoring exam questions ‘has successfully been in place within the Charedi schools throughout England for many years’

Yesodey Hatorah Senior Girls School in Hackney said that the system of censoring exam questions has to date has never posed a problem with the Examination Boards.

RSPCA appealing for ‘moggie midwives’ this Mother’s Day

The RSPCA is appealing for foster carers to look after pregnant cats and newborn kittens this Mother’s Day.

Boeing, Japan Transocean Air Announce Selection of 12 Next-Generation 737s

Boeing and Japan Transocean Air (JTA) announced the airline's selection of 12 Next-Generation 737-800 airplanes.

Boeing Statement on ANA Widebody Airplane Selection

Boeing is pleased that ANA today announced the selection of 40 Boeing widebody airplanes for its strategic fleet renewal.

Why east London needs a new bridge

London is expanding east and needs a new bridge connecting north and south.

IET Award finalist in Marks and Spencer’s Leading Ladies campaign

Roma Agrawal is hitting headlines alongside big names such as Annie Lennox and Rita Ora, after Marks and Spencer chose the 30-year-old structural engineer as one of their ‘Leading Ladies’.

RSPCA warns of rabies threat from illegally imported puppies

MPs discuss measures to halt imported European puppies.

This email has been sent to you by Politics.co.uk because you previously registered on our site. To stop receiving emails like this please update your preferences or unsubscribe here. Politics.co.uk, South Quay Plaza 2, 183 Marsh Wall, London, E14 9SH. Registered in England with company number 07092149.

No comments:

Post a Comment