Friday, 7 March 2014

Week in Review: The ugliness of a Ukip Britain

Did your email system distort this newsletter? Click here to see it online. To make sure emails from Politics.co.uk don’t go into your junk folder, please add us to your email contacts. To stop receiving emails such as this, please update your preferences or unsubscribe here.

"It was rush hour, from Charing Cross. It was the stopper going out. We stopped at London Bridge, New Cross, Hither Green. It wasn't until after we got past Grove Park that I could actually hear English being audibly spoken in the carriage. Does that make me feel slightly awkward? Yes."

With these words, spoken by Nigel Farage at the Ukip spring conference last weekened, something changed. Many years ago Ukip was a party of "looneys, fruitcakes and closet racists". Then, slowly, it turned into the party's for an 'open and honest' debate about immigration. And now it was crawling back into the dark nether regions of the British body politick, the sweaty bits in between creases of skin which no shower could ever clean.

There was a subtle change in the media coverage afterwards, with a handful of commentators observing something sinister beneath the charming Faragist bluster. It didn't help that the party's slogan, unveiled at its spring conference, was once used by the BNP.

The party was asked pressing questions about its MEP's voting record in the European parliament. Nigel Farage countered with the predictable excuse that his intention is to neuter the parliament, not contribute to it. It is not a particularly convincing answer. One could do much more damage to the EU with legislative amendments than  by sitting at home whinging about it.

On Friday, Robert Halfon, the Tory backbencher who talks so much sense you occasionally forget which party he's in, said Ukip acted as a cleansing agent for the Conservatives - sucking out their more lunatic supporters.

But he also went one step further - a step he may not have gone were it not for Farage's comments over the weekend. In a section on Ukip MEP Gerard Batten's demand for every Muslim to sign a declaration of non-violence, he said: "[This] to me is literally akin to the Nazis saying Jews should wear a yellow star. I genuinely find it abhorrent and frightening. I'm amazed that man is still an MEP, how someone could say such a thing and then not apologise for it."

Ukip seemed as if it was on the verge of finally recieving a more critical response from the press than it had thus far. Most criticisms of the party are invariably met by a barrage of online attacks complaining that the Westminster/media/EU/Marxist/BBC establishment is intent on destroying Farage's common-sense, stands-to-reason, man-of-the-people uprising. It is an ironic answer, given the party has enjoyed all the coverage and none of the criticism of the three mainstream offerings - not to mention the total media blackout on other small parties, like the Greens or Respect.

But, as Farage himself points out, the main function of Ukip is not to win elections. It is to shift the political debate in Britain decisively to the right. In this, at least, it appears the party has been an unmitigated success.

As the week came to an end - and events in Ukraine remained serious enough to warrant talk of a fundamental realignment of European power - the press were mostly questioning the prime minister about the nationality of his cleaner.

The questioning was not as racist as it sounds, but it was profoundly revealing: Cameron had allowed the rhetoric of his party on immigration to become so severe that the nationality of his domestic assistant was now a political issue.

This was mostly the result of a very troubling speech by the new immigration secretary, James Brokenshire. He used his first outing to strongly suggest that immigration had negative outcomes for the majority of the population, that British workers lost jobs to migrants and that only rich cosmopolitans benefitted from it. This raised questions as to whether any of those rich cosmopolitans he sits next to on the government front bench might also hire foreign nannies and cleaners. Or for that matter, his predessesor, who mostly certainly did. The speech was quickly and colourfully attacked by business leaders and Vince Cable.

No 10 spent most of the week trying to explain why it had not published a report on the 'displacement' of British jobs by immigrants. The reason was that it contradicted the government message on the need to get tough on immigration and - for what it's worth - Theresa May's oft-repeated assertion that 23 British jobs are lost for every 100 migrants. It's a statistic with all the academic credibility of a One Direction concert so it surprised no-one that the home secretary enjoyed using it. Her civil servants eventually had a whisper in her ear.

Cameron's reluctance to publish a report finding that things are basically going OK runs against decades of political law. Typically governments say that they are doing well and will soon be doing even better. It is the opposition's job to suggest otherwise. But Cameron has become so fearful of the Ukip beast - and his own backbenchers, who are honestly closer to Ukip than their leader - that he is now intent on rubbishing his own record in office to pretend that things are going worse than they really are. It is a remarkable sight.

This is partly to do with his own offhand and deeply counter-productive pledge to reduce net migration to the tens of thousands - a goal he is in no position to honour given that it is dependent on how many Brits leave the country. Now that figures show immigrant numbers creeping up again, he must rue the day he made the comment.

Eventually the report was published, but only once it could be timed with an announcement by the home secretary on the extent of police corruption in the Met. It popped up on the web almost the second she got on her feet.

For all that, the public inquiry launched by May in that statement - the latest in a long line for the Stephen Lawrence family - was a new low in the Met's relationship with Westminster. The fact a law is needed specifically to tackle police corruption is an ugly milestone in British politics.

And if Ukip continue to have this corrosive effect on the standard of debate, it will not be the last ugly milestone we speak of.

Best of News

Justice screeches to a halt amid nationwide legal protest

Legal professionals hold placards during a protest against cuts to legal aid outside Southwark Crown Court in January

High profile court cases such as the trial of Max Clifford screech to a halt today, as thousands of lawyers walk out for the second time this year

Blair 'reaching for cheque book' to rescue Labour's bank balance

Tony Blair's office strenuously denies he is now worth £75 million

Source close to ex-PM confirms a big donation is possible

New blow for Salmond as poll shows decline in independence support

Salmond: Osborne gambit a 'monumental error'

Alex Salmond accuses George Osborne of a "monumental error" in ruling out currency union with an independent Scotland, even as a new poll shows a drop in support for the 'yes' camp

Boris: Extremist parents are child abusers

Boris Johnson's call seems to reflect the wishes of the intelligence services

Children taught extremist views by their parents should be placed in social services, Boris Johnson claims

We won't repeal Gove's school reforms, admits Labour

Tristram Hunt: Gove's reforms have been "successful".

Labour will not undo Michael Gove's school reforms, many of which have been "successful" the shadow education secretary admits.

Boris Johnson launches furious tirade against 'liar' Osborne

Boris Johnson 'furious' at attempts to draw him back to Parliament

Boris Johnson launches a furious attack on George Osborne, accusing him of trying to wreck his chances of becoming prime minister.

Miliband to blame for Ukraine crisis, say Tories

Heavily-armed soldiers maintain watch in a street in Simferopol, Ukraine

Ed Miliband is personally to blame for the current crisis in Ukraine, a senior Conservative minister claims.

Best of Comment and Analysis

'If you want a sustainable life it's not for you': The reality of criminal law

An anonymous legal professional lays open the real struggles of the criminal Bar

One legal professional, talking on condition of anonymity, explains the reality of life at the Bar

WATCH: Scotland's currency union dilemma explained in 30 seconds

Salmond's currency union dilemma in 30 seconds

Confused by what'll happen to the pound if Scotland goes independent? Well, fret no longer.

Immigrant Stories: Lenin and the fight for cleaners' pay

Striking cleaners and their supporters on the picket line at SOAS university

An occasional series of Immigrant Stories, shining a light on the people in Britain's immigration system

Why can't science and politics get along?

Andrew Miller is chair of parliament's science and technology committee

Politicians have a patchy record on paying attention to scientists – to the detriment of us all.

Comment: The UN's bullying tactics on drugs show how scared it is of reform

Ian Dunt: 'It is as comprehensive an admittance of defeat as could be imagined'

Prohibitionists have resorted to threats and intimidation to keep their disastrous system of drug control alive.

Comment: Cameron just can't get over his ideology phobia

Alex Stevenson: Fearing the consequences of admitting that the Tory approach is ideologically driven comes at a cost

It's his most ideologically-driven speech so far – but David Cameron doesn't want you thinking the Conservatives are motivated by anything as base as 'ideology'.

The court judgement on loving an immigrant

Separated: Brits are being forced to pick between their partner or their country

Nestled away in the court of appeal: a case which decides whether Brits can live with the person they love

Comment: The press are guilty of double standards on child sexualisation

Betiel Baraki: The printed press are guilty of double standards on child sexualisation

Popular culture is being increasingly 'pornified' - and our newspapers are partly to blame

Podcast

Podcast: Temperatures rising over 38 Degrees

Power to the people: But some say 38 Degrees is undermined by being partisan

Is the internet-mobilising 38 Degrees a spamming organisation – or at the front of an online revolution in democracy?

Voice reacts angrily to Michael Gove's "deprofessionalising"

Government and STRB deprofessionalising teachers and early years professionals.

Number of animals rescued by RSPCA from floods doubles in just three days

The RSPCA has released the latest rescue figures for flood stricken Britain - with almost 400 animals saved since Monday.

International summit on illegal trade begins in London

Strong measures sought to protect elephants, rhinos, tigers and other threatened species from poaching.

Celebrating 9 years of hunt ban with facts and myths

Charities mark success of Hunting Act most successful piece of wild animal legislation.

Extra tax support from HMRC welcome - but difficulties must be resolved

LITRG welcomes new HMRC service for taxpayers who need extra support but concerns remain.

Boeing, Nok Air Announce Commitment to Order 737 MAXs, Next-Generation 737s

Efficiency of 737 supports Nok Air’s low-cost model.

BSA comments on the Banking Standards Review consultation

BSA welcomes the Banking Standards Review consultation paper from Sir Richard Lambert and will be responding.

This email has been sent to you by Politics.co.uk because you previously registered on our site. To stop receiving emails like this please update your preferences or unsubscribe here. Politics.co.uk, South Quay Plaza 2, 183 Marsh Wall, London, E14 9SH. Registered in England with company number 07092149.

No comments:

Post a Comment