| Did your email system distort this newsletter? Click here to see it online. To make sure emails from Politics.co.uk don’t go into your junk folder, please add us to your email contacts. To stop receiving emails such as this, please update your preferences or unsubscribe here. | |
 |    |
| In the aftermath of by-elections, politicians and journalists talk a lot about what individuals parties did wrong. They talk about the perils of incumbency and 'giving them a bloody nose' and then they promise to listen to the voters. This was never useful and now it is utterly irrelevant. The results in Clacton and Heywood and Middleton were not about the Tories, or Labour, or even Ukip. They were an attack on all of Westminster. Voters can barely tell the main political parties apart. Labour came within 617 votes of losing a safe seat. The Tories were absolutely hammered, gleefully, Brazilian World Cup style, by one of their own. But it wasn't about them as individual parties, it was about them as a Westminster class. Miliband instantly pledged to care more about immigration. It is a nonsense response. David Cameron has been aping Ukip for two years. It’s done nothing to quell their support and plenty to lose him centrist voters in Tory-Lib Dem marginals. Ukip is not a policy problem. When voters express anger at Westminster, they are not just angry with one or two parties within it. It is all of them. In fact, as I wrote last month, it is more than that – it is the media and lobby groups and think tanks and even charities. It is the Westminster industry. Douglas Carswell did not win because he was tougher on immigration. He won because he represented an opportunity to kick Westminster. That's why, despite their other political differences, Ukip bear more than a passing resemblance to the Scottish National party (SNP), who also channelled an anti-Westminster mood for their own political ends. The victory in Clacton is not the explosion which finally brought Westminster down, but if Mark Reckless wins next month it could precipitate a stream of Tory MPs jumping ship. After all, Reckless does not have the ideal constituency, or the personal branding, which Carswell enjoys. If he wins – and current polling suggests he will – it means anyone could potentially do it. There are plenty of MPs to the right of the pair who would be tempted. And then there is a general election, in which members of the public will answer a very specific question. Does their dislike for Westminster trump their dislike for one particular party? If it's the former, the earthquake will continue and politics could be shaken of all its presumptions. If it's the latter, we're back to something like business-as-usual, with voters holding their nose and voting for one party in order to obstruct another. That's what Liberal Democrats are counting on. The party is sure George Osborne's pledge to hammer the working age poor and pass the proceeds on to high earners plays directly into their equidistance strategy. In an effort to get Kippers back in the fold the Tories have drifted back to their nasty party safety zone, and centrist voters – even those concerned with paying down the deficit – aren't buying it. Perhaps that's true. We shall see next May. But by the time Clegg was making his closing speech, one would have had to be very generous or very naive to think voters would distinguish him from Miliband or Cameron. The Liberal Democrat leader told his audience he wanted to challenge the status quo, but like Miliband before him he had little in the way of concrete plans. The anti-Westminster mood is bigger than political parties. It is about the kind of politics we do and how we discuss it. It is about actions, rather than policy. It is about ideas, rather than focus groups. And it is ultimately about how markets and centralised power left people feeling they'd been robbed of control over their lives. None of the three parties understand. They cannot provide the solution because they are the problem. Best of the weekHome Office urged to use force against detained children Panel calls on Home Office to detain more children and use force against them to get them out the country Defeated Ed Davey: I wasn't defeated "I don't feel it's a defeat," Ed Davey told me. He was speaking immediately after suffering the Lib Dem leadership's most embarrassing defeat of this year's conference. Community Treatment Orders: Politics and psychiatry in a culture of fear Politics still affects how mentally ill people are treated. Comment: You're helping pay for torture British-sponsored abuse of tribal peoples' rights continues to the present day. Analysis: Vince Cable learns to be useful Vince Cable has spent much of the last four years being a thorn in his leader's side. But now, as today's autumn conference speech in Glasgow shows, things have changed. With the general election looming the chastened business secretary has become an asset once again. | Cameron's Offer of ‘Jam’ TomorrowOn the face of it, raising the tax threshold sounds great, but the problem is this; when you earn so little, tax really isn't the problem. It’s the amount that you earn that is the real issue. House purchase lending in August down 3% on JulyNew CML data on the characteristics of lending in August show that lending declined slightly compared to July, the first month-on-month drop in house purchase lending volume since February this year. CML welcomes FPC's view on Help to BuyWe welcome the financial policy committee's (FPC) view that the chancellor does not need to make any changes to the Help to Buy mortgage guarantee scheme. Clegg announcement on introduction of maximum waiting times for mental health is a ‘watershed moment’ says charityMillions of lives could be improved by the introduction of the first ever maximum waiting times for NHS mental health services, according to the charity Rethink Mental Illness. Act now to prepare for higher rates!No-one knows for sure when the Bank of England’s monetary policy committee will make its first decision to raise interest rates, but there some practical steps that people can take now to help prepare for it. National Grid Energy Efficiency Innovation Award, administered by NEANational Grid is inviting applications to a new £400,000 Energy Efficiency Innovation Award Scheme, which will support major innovations to tackle fuel poverty and deliver energy efficiency solutions in disadvantaged communities. 'Let teachers reclaim the classroom' - NASUWT challenge to the Lib DemsChris Keates, General Secretary of the NASUWT, was joined by Schools Minister David Laws at Beyond 2015: Reclaiming the Classroom, a fringe meeting organised by the NASUWT at the Liberal Democrats Party Conference in Glasgow. |
